Cultural Studies: Two Paradigms by Stuart Hall (UGC NET English Unit VII)

     Stuart Hall: Brief Overview

ü  Born on 3 Feb 1932 in Kingston,  Jamaica (then a colony of UK) into a middle class family of Indian, African & British descent- Caribbean

ü  A Cultural Theorist/ Sociologist

ü  Lived and worked in UK since 1951

ü  Studied at Merton College, University of Oxford

ü  One of the founding figures of British Cultural Studies/ The Birmingham School of Cultural Studies

ü  Served as the Director of CCCS (Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies) at Birmingham University  from 1968 to 1979

ü  Professor  of Sociology at the Open University (1979- 1997)

ü  Now, a Professor Emeritus

ü  Married to Catherine Hall, a Feminist Professor at University College, London

ü  Founding  editor of NEW LEFT REVIEW

ü  Major Works

§  Situating Marx: Evaluations & Departures (1972) – article

§  Encoding & Decoding in the Television Discourse (1973)- article

§  The Hard Road to Renewal (1988)

§  Formations of Modernity (1992)

§  Questions of Cultural Identity (1996)

§  Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices (1997)

ü  His works center on the interconnections between ideology, identity, culture and politics- Increased concern with postmodernism and issues of race during 1990’s- throughout his academic years, he has argued for ‘the relevance of sophisticated Marxism to the understanding of contemporary social formations as well as a force for social change’.

ü  Founding Editor of Soundings: A Journal of Politics and Culture

ü  A proponent of Reception Theory- This approach to textual analysis focuses on the scope for negotiation and opposition on the part of the audience

 


CULTURAL STUDIES: TWO PARADIGMS

                                 (Paradigm- approaches to the study of culture/ model)

 

§   In “Cultural Studies: Two Paradigms”, Stuart Hall articulates two paradigms or two types of approaches to the study of culture. They comprise a ‘culturalist’ strand deriving from the works of Hoggart, Raymond Williams and E P Thompson & a ‘structuralist’ strand which owed first to Levi- Strauss and Ferdinand de Saussure and then to the work of Althusser.

      The culturalist strand in CS is interrupted by the arrival on the intellectual scene of the ‘Structuralisms’…

      Stuart Hall presents the differences between the two paradigms on the basis of the concept of the process/ purpose of culture, the importance of ‘experience’, the positioning of abstractions like the existence of dialectical relations between conditions & consciousness, and the function of ideology.

 

1. CULTURALISM (HOGGART, WILLIAMS & THOMPSON)

 

ü  The founding fathers of CCCS- Richard Hoggart, Raymond Williams & E P Thompson- represent the moment of culturalism

Hoggart’s The Uses of Literacy, Raymond Williams’ Culture and Society, E P Thompson’s The Making of the English Working Class are the seminal works in culturalism.

The Uses of Literacy represents a tradition of English working class culture.

Culture and Society presents the culture- and- society tradition of a particular group of English intellectuals. The Making of the English Working Class presents

a tradition of working- class political culture

 

Hall has characterized these authors as ‘culturalists’. He analyzed the projects of these 3 authors as acts of ‘recovery’ and of constituting traditions.

 

ü  According to Hall, the significance of the “culturalist paradigm” is that it insists on an understanding of culture not as a set of privileged texts, but rather as the systems of meanings embodied in all social practices.

ü  In Culturalism, experience is the ground/ terrain of ‘the lived’. Its focus is on how people experience their conditions of life.

ü  The ‘culturalists’ (Williams & Thompson) view popular culture as an expression of the working class / expressions of class relations.

ü  Hall describes Culturalists’ definition of culture as “the sum of the available descriptions through which societies make sense of and reflect their common experiences”. This definition has ‘democratized’ culture from an elite status. i.e, from the ‘best’ or ‘privileged’ to a framework that involves the common or ordinary.

ü  As per the culturalist definition, ‘culture is everything’; All things such as art, commodity, ideas, process etc created by community (everyone regardless of status) possess the ability to define and redefine meaning. This approach opens up all cultural phenomena to criticism. This dissolves the traditional modernist definition of high/ low culture.

 

2. STRUCTURALISM (LEVI STRAUSS, SAUSSURE  & ALTHUSSER)

ü   The strength of Structuralist paradigm is that it critiques the humanism and experimentalism of the culturalist paradigm.

ü  Structuralism insists that ‘experience’ can’t be the ground of analysis. It is not an authenticating source. One can only ‘live’ and experience one’s conditions in & through the categories, classifications and frameworks of the culture. These categories do not arise from or in experience.  Experience is the effect or product of classifications, frameworks, language or discourses (social structures).

ü  The Marxist Structuralists see popular culture as imposed set of meaning.

ü  To the structuralists, the study of culture is not in the sum of cultural phenomena, but in the underlying relationships/ contradictions.

ü  The term ‘structural’ gives the idea of culture as rigid and determinative.

ü  In this arena, questions of ideology, structures of domination & the work of intellectuals take over from questions about culture or experience.

ü  Structuralists stress on ‘determinate conditions’.

 

CULTURALISM & STRUCTURALISM

 

                     Culturalism stresses the ordinariness of culture and the active, creative capacity of people to construct shared meaningful practices. Empirical work, which is emphasized within the culturalist tradition, explores the way that active human beings create cultural meanings. There is a focus on lived experience and the adoption of a broadly anthropological definition of culture which describes it as an everyday lived process not confined to ‘high’ art.

 

                     Culturalism, particularly for Williams and Thompson, is a form of historical cultural materialism which traces the unfolding of meaning over time, exploring culture in the context of its material conditions of production and reception. 

 

                     If culturalism takes meaning to be its central category and casts it as the product of active human agents, structuralism speaks instead of signifying practices which generate meaning as an outcome of structures or predictable regularities which lie outside of any given person. Structuralism is anti- humanist in its decentering of human agents from the heart of inquiry, favoring a form of analysis in which phenomena have meaning only in relation to other phenomena within a systematic structure of which no particular person is the source. A structuralist understanding of culture is concerned with the systems of relations of an underlying structure.

 

§  According to Hall, CS emerged as a distinct problematic through the interventions in literary studies of Hoggart & Williams. The Structuralist intervention constituted a powerful challenge to this paradigm, making work along similar lines possible.

 

§  Hall is of the view that they are contesting paradigms & they are a part of a historical narrative of the emergence and development of Cultural Studies. i.e, CS is constituted by opposing theoretical discourses, which are both necessary but limited. To him, some kind of conceptual transformation or epistemological break is necessary.

 

§  Hall concludes that there are two major and as yet unreconciled paradigms for the analysis of popular culture (culturalism & structuralism). He argues that culturalism’s strength corresponds to the weakness of structuralism. Structuralism is unable to explain those phenomena which culturalism privileges.

 

§  Hall attempts to chart a course for the future of CS. To him, one can ‘appropriate’ the strength and avoid the weakness of each approach, which will go beyond both paradigms.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Banaras Hindu University (BHU) M. A. English Entrance previous years questions papers (2010 to 2019)

Image
Banaras Hindu University: The Capital of All Knowledge Questions papers of previous years are important milestone for any exam. These papers give the students guidelines of which way and how to proceed in their preparation. Going through the questions gives them the insight and clarity needed for any exam. Banaras Hindu University (BHU) is the largest residential university of Asia and has its rank "Third" among all the universities of India. Lots of students have their dreams of becoming a part of this eminent university. So, I am here providing you all with the questions papers of the entrance test following the latest pattern and trend in Post Graduate English Literature. Click the following links to download the respective old question paper:    BHU entrance question_M.A. ENGLISH 2010   https://drive.google.com/file/d/189LtnwP0-QK4qZtq47lLWQViy3wa7TZu/view?usp=sharing   BHU entrance question_M.A. ENGLISH 2011 https://drive.google.com/file/d/13Sk67LcnK6fVc1shFUQhY...
Read more

Use of Irony in Ralph Ellison's "Invisible Man"

Image
Irony, the use of words to convey an idea that departs from its literal meaning, underpins many of the protagonist’s earliest experiences in Ellison's Invisible Man . In particular, Ellison’s use of structural irony reveals his authorial goals because we, along with the mature writer-narrator whom we meet in the prologue, observe an incredibly naïve central character stumbling towards self-understanding. This pervasiveness of structural irony, or the reader’s perpetual sense of knowing more than the narrator, allows Ellison to have fun as he inserts his protagonist into various conundrums. In addition to injecting bursts of humor, the comic aspects of his narrator’s experiences facilitate Ellison’s artful handling of the weighty issues that he invites readers to explore. The novel’s first episode sets this tone.  In the battle royal scene, the narrator’s earnest recitation of his Washingtonian valedictory speech, one which exhorts his audience of white segregationists to join hands...
Read more

Old English Religious/ Christian Poetry (Caedmon, Cynewulf)

Image
    The coming of Christianity introduced the Anglo-Saxons with the Holy Bible that influenced a rich body of Christian literature. After conversion to Christianity the Anglo-Saxon poets turned away from pagan themes, and sought subjects for their poetry in the Bible or in the lives of saints. They did not, however, wholly abandon the pagan sentiments and ideas, but used them after getting them filtered through their new religion. They applied the techniques of Anglo-Saxon heroic poetry to purely Christian themes. As a result, the old English religious poetry shows a great blending of pagan and Christian elements. There are two glaring stars in the sky of Anglo-Saxon religious poetry- Caedmon and Cynewulf.   The story of Caedmon ’s miraculous transformation into the first religious poet of England and his nine-lined Hymn of Creation is contained in Venerable Bede’s Latin work, Ecclesiastical History of the English People.  Caedmon was a layman at the monastery of Wh...
Read more

Narrative Technique of Ralph Ellison's "Invisible Man"

Image
  Invisible Man can be seen as a Bildungsroman (novel of education), similar to Voltaire’s Candide , which captures the personal growth and development of the protagonist. The novel focuses on the life of the Invisible Man as a young man and his experiences from adulthood through maturity. The narrator is older now as he reflects on his life story backwards. The novel is framed by a Prologue and an Epilogue. The story opens in the present, switches to flashback, and then returns to the present, but a step forward from the Prologue. Writing down the story has helped the hero to make up his mind about things. Leonard J. Deutsch attributes the complexity of the novel in part to this juxtaposition of perspectives of the “I” of the naïve boy and the “I” of the older, wiser narrator. Warren French has described the formal organization of the narrative as “a series of nested boxes that an individual, trapped in the constricting center, seeks to escape.” Several critics cite the use ...
Read more

Wole Soyinka’s Theatre: the “Fourth Stage”

  The “Fourth Stage” is uniquely Soyinka’s interpretation of Yoruba mythology in which there are four parallel worlds of the living, the dead, the unborn and the chthonic (underworld) realm, where the ambiguities of cultural identities are contested. These worlds exist in a non-hierarchical manner, and their membranous nature allows the dwellers to access these different worlds at will. This interpretation is the central thesis of Soyinka in his essays, “Morality and Aesthetics in the Ritual Archetype”, “Drama and the African Worldview” and “The Fourth Stage”. The main argument is that African myth and ritual (exemplary in Yoruba mythology) are not discrete background cultural objects but form the continuing aesthetic and social foregrounding of African society. By starting off with Nietzsche’s theory of the ritual roots of classical Greek theatre, Soyinka explains the roots of African (Yoruba) ritual tragedy in the myth of Ogun and the sacral rites depicting his prowess in bat...
Read more

Significance of the Battle Royal scene in Ralph Ellison's "Invisible Man"

Image
  Invisible Man is invited to present his valedictorian speech to a group of wealthy white patrons at a Southern gentlemen’s club. When he arrives, however, he is forced to participate in a blindfolded ‘battle royal’ against a group of men he believes to be his ‘peers’: adolescent African American males. The irony of the situation is, he finds no commonality with these youths, only bitter rivalry. The hypocrisy of the Southern socio-economy is figuratively actualised in the poignant symbolism of the young black adolescents, who are induced to beat each other to bloody pulps for the amusement of rich white patrons, with the promise of coins as reward (which, they later discover, are counterfeit). Like many members of the Jazz Age intelligentsia before him, Ellison is interested in satirising the cultural apologue of an American ‘aristocracy’ built on slavery in a pure, high capitalist society where there has never been a decline of the ruling class. The mere prospect of wealth enf...
Read more

Ralph Ellison's "Invisible Man" as a Bildungsroman (novel of growth/development)

Image
  In the traditional European prototype, coming-of-age is charted through the representation of ordeals and life lessons which the young protagonist or Bildungsheld must overcome in order to achieve their harmonious course of maturation. The American model forgoes this necessity of harmony. Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man (1952) is one such coming-of-age narrative , following the pedagogical and experiential education of an African American adolescent in the 1920s and 30s. Ellison subverts the inefficiencies of representing race in American literature and culture that had come before him. At the same time, the author illuminates the hypocrisies of racial and ideological identity politics in a post-Abolition American society. The linear temporality of the traditional Bildungsroman form is subverted by Ellison’s reflexive use of direct, first person narration in the present and past tense, featuring an ironic use of the in medias res technique with flashbacks. It is indeed ironic ...
Read more

Important Short Stories (UGC NET Unit III)

Image
  James Joyce Araby The Dead Eveline The Sisters   Mark Twain The Celebrated Jumping Frog of Calaveras County The Man That Corrupted Hadleyburg The Invalid's Story No. 44, The Mysterious Stranger A Dog's Tale A Ghost's Story The Stolen White Elephant   Washington Irving The Devil and Tom Walker The Legend of Sleepy Hollow Rip Van Winkle   Gabriel Garcia Marquez The Handsomest Drowned Man in the World A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings The Woman Who Came at Six O'Clock Eyes of a Blue Dog Death Constant Beyond Love The Autumn of the Patriarch   Ralph Ellison King of the Bingo Game   Saki (Hector Hugh Munro) The Open Window   Joseph Conrad The Secret Sharer   Ernest Hemingway The Short, Happy Life of Francis Macomber Hills Like White Elephants In Another Country A Clean, Well-lighted Place The Snows of Kilimanjaro The Killers Indian Camp The Undefeated   Ray Bradbury ...
Read more

Nadine Gordimer's "Burger's Daughter": Narrative Technique

Image
  The narrative of Nadine Gordimer’s novel Burger’s Daughter is in two modes of narration ; one is a third person narration by the omniscient author , and the other is by Rosa herself . The latter, Rosa's own narration, is very much in the stream-of-consciousness technique . The double discourse of the private disruptive voice and the public conventional tone informs the narrative structure of the novel. The narration alternates between first person and third person- "My version and theirs". The narration by the omniscient author is like a detached record of the happenings in Rosa Burger's life. The opening is a perfect example of this third person narrative: “ Among the group of people waiting at the fortress was a schoolgirl in a brown and yellow uniform holding a green eiderdown quilt and, by the loop at its neck, a red hot-water bottle. ” But at times, even this detached omniscient authoress penetrates into the labyrinths of Rosa Burger's mind to explore th...
Read more

New Trends in English Literature

             The 21 st  century has proved to the world that English literature is no longer the sole province of the imperial England. Although English literature started and flourished in England, it has gone on to sow the seeds of creativity in English in other parts of the world. Interestingly, the English people themselves paved the way for the unexpected developments that we witness today. When the English colonizers went to America, they began to write their own literature of the Americas. Similarly, those English men and women who went to Australia began the process of a new literature called Australian literature. And so is the case with Canada, India, and Africa. With colonization in some parts of the world, especially, Africa and Asia, there emerged a new literature which later came to be known as the Commonwealth literature, New Literature in English, postcolonial literature and so on. Not to be left out, even those countries which we...
Read more